Feb 9, 2025 Story by: Editor
The documentary Seeds, which debuted at the Sundance Film Festival, offers a deeply personal account of Black generational farmers in the American South, presented through striking black-and-white cinematography. From its opening frame—set at a funeral—the film establishes an immediate sense of connection, signaling that the story is being told from an intimate perspective.
A Personal Approach
Director Brittany Shyne ensures that Seeds does not follow the usual outsider’s narrative, where viewers are first introduced to the subjects and their background before delving into their challenges. Instead, the documentary immerses audiences in the world of a farming community grappling with a crisis, told from the viewpoint of someone who shares their lived experience.
At the funeral, the film follows Clara Williams as she rides home with her granddaughter, explaining where the body in the hearse will be taken. The camera places the audience within this private moment, turning them into quiet observers of a family’s personal exchange.
The Strength of Observation
This observational approach allows viewers to grasp the struggles this community faces. Clara serves as the narrative thread, guiding the audience through the experiences of generations of farmers as they candidly discuss their concerns about the future, ongoing discrimination, and more.
At the heart of the documentary is 89-year-old Carlie Williams, the eldest member of the family. In one particularly moving scene, he visits an optometrist and is taken aback by the high cost of treatment. Unable to afford the glasses, he asks if there is an alternative, highlighting the financial hardships he faces despite a lifetime of farming.
A Story of Legacy and Change
Through its stunning monochromatic visuals, Seeds captures the emotions and resilience of this farming community. Shyne’s cinematography remains unobtrusive, allowing moments of joy, sorrow, and the demand for rights to unfold naturally. The film portrays a way of life built on shared responsibility—one that resonates deeply with the older generation.
However, a quiet shift is evident. While the film subtly conveys the theme of legacy, it also reveals that younger generations are increasingly choosing different paths. This contrast is complemented by more direct critiques of governmental support for farmers. One farmer voices his frustration, saying, “The president said he had our back. I voted for him. Yet nothing has been done.” This statement raises questions about the future of their activism under the current administration.
A Thoughtful, Timely Documentary
Seeds is a deeply assured documentary that rewards patient viewers with an immersive understanding of its subjects. The film invites audiences to grow alongside this community, fostering a connection that lingers. Brittany Shyne has crafted a delicate yet powerful film that feels profoundly relevant—one of the standout documentaries of the year. Source: Hindustan Times
