Dec 17, 2024 Story by: Editor
Rep. David Scott (D-Ga.) opted out of a Wednesday interview with the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC), sparking frustration among members as the race for the leading Democratic role on the House Agriculture Committee intensifies.
Scott, the current ranking member of the influential panel, is being challenged by two junior Democrats, Reps. Jim Costa (D-Calif.) and Angie Craig (D-Minn.), who are competing for the position in the next Congress. While all three candidates were invited to discuss their candidacies with the CBC, only Costa and Craig attended the meeting, with Scott notably absent.
Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.) expressed disappointment over Scott’s no-show, noting that his seniority within the CBC would have made him a strong contender for the role. However, Thompson cautioned that Scott’s decision to skip the interview could prompt some members to reconsider their support.
“Obviously, if David had chosen to participate, it would have been easy. He’s there. But you have to participate. … And when you choose an alternate path to participation, it could come back to haunt you,” Thompson said.
“It was a lot of concern — and support,” Thompson continued. “But I don’t think it would have been an issue had he decided to come. [Scott’s absence] gives people reason to do something else.”
Scott’s office did not respond to requests for comment regarding his absence.
The contest comes as House Democrats revisit the long-standing debate over the role of seniority in determining key committee positions. For decades, the CBC has championed seniority as a critical criterion, arguing it has been instrumental in empowering minority lawmakers historically denied such opportunities.
However, the caucus has gradually softened its stance, with leaders emphasizing that seniority should be considered alongside other factors.
“Seniority without competency, or without ability, is a challenge,” said Rep. Troy Carter (D-La.). “So we will make sure that we will give deference to seniority, but we want the very best person to serve.”
Craig, recognizing the importance of experience, acknowledged Scott’s contributions and support during his rise to the top of the Agriculture Committee in 2020. However, she argued for fresh leadership and innovative ideas.
“I respect seniority in our system. It’s led to, historically, a number of folks that had been underrepresented getting chairmanships. Certainly, David Scott was the most senior person, and I supported him,” Craig said.
“But I also believe there are moments of time in a party, and in our system, where we realize we need new direction, and perhaps new thinking, and new ideas,” she added. “And I hope the Democratic caucus is open to that right now.” Source: The Hill
