Black Politics Now
  • Home
  • Business
  • Civil Rights
  • Criminal Justice
  • Education
  • Elections
  • Health
  • Policy
  • Voting Rights
  • Reparations
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Register
Black Politics Now
  • Home
  • Business
  • Civil Rights
  • Criminal Justice
  • Education
  • Elections
  • Health
  • Policy
  • Voting Rights
  • Reparations
No Result
View All Result
Black Politics Now
No Result
View All Result

Struggle for control of public libraries in full swing across the Deep South

Black Politics Now by Black Politics Now
March 17, 2025
in Research
0
assorted books on shelf

Photo by Ivo Rainha on Pexels.com

74
SHARES
1.2k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

March 17, 2025 Story by: Editor

You might also like

Appeals court blocks private lawsuits under Voting Rights Act’s disability assistance provision

Who is Rep. Senfronia Thompson, a member of the Texas House Select Committee on Congressional Redistricting

WWII USS Utah survivor Clark Simmons’ 1998 Pearl Harbor interview removed from National Park Service website

Libraries were once considered safe havens for knowledge and learning. However, in 2025, they have transformed into battlegrounds.

For the past decade, a fierce struggle over library books has unfolded across the South. On one side are white supremacist and Christian nationalist groups, and on the other, an unexpected alliance of progressives, educators, and Black leaders.

Just two months into Donald Trump’s second presidency, his aggressive stance against diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) has intensified these cultural clashes.

A report released by PEN America on February 27 analyzed banned books from the 2023-2024 school year. It revealed that 36% of the 4,218 books banned featured characters or people of color. This figure increases to 44% when considering only history books or biographies, with 26% specifically focusing on Black individuals. Additionally, 25% of all banned books included LGBTQ+ characters or themes.

“Book banning is not new to this country. It’s just on a whole other level …” said Lacie Sutherland, a former Prattville librarian now working at the Montgomery City-County Public Library.

New legislation from conservative state legislatures is pushing censorship further. In Alabama, a proposed bill would fine librarians $10,000 if they fail to act on book removal requests. Louisiana lawmakers passed a 2024 law allowing parish governments to dismiss library boards without cause. Florida led the nation in book challenges in 2023, with 2,672 titles contested under state law, according to the American Library Association. In response, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed a 2024 law limiting public challenges to books, acknowledging that the previous 2022 legislation was overly broad.

“While some of the initial attention has been focused on LGBTQ books,” said Sam Boyd, a senior supervising attorney in Florida with the Southern Poverty Law Center’s Democracy: Education and Youth litigation team, “there has been an effort to restrict books featuring Black characters or written by Black authors. And these attacks have certainly created a chilling effect on educators and schools.”

Controlling the Narrative

In Lafayette, Louisiana, the group “Warriors for Christ” filed a lawsuit in 2018 to prevent the library from hosting “Drag Queen Story Time” (DQST), where LGBTQ+ individuals read to children.

By 2021, Robert Judge, an opponent of DQST, had become the chair of the Lafayette Parish Library Board of Control. His tenure was marked by police interventions at public meetings and the controversial firing of the library director, which violated state open meeting laws. Though he later stepped down as chairman, Judge continues to serve on the board, supporting Christian nationalist policies. One such policy decision—rejecting a federal grant for voter education—spurred the formation of a grassroots resistance group.

“The very first salvo in this new phase of the library war here was an overtly racist one, right? Because voting rights are something that disproportionately affects Black and Brown people,” said Lynette Mejia, chair of Lafayette Citizens Against Censorship. “So that’s when it got to the point where I said to myself, ‘OK, they’re not going away.’ This is a sustained attack.”

Mejia initially observed the controversy surrounding DQST without direct involvement. However, her lifelong connection to libraries motivated her to act when voter education funding was denied.

“I started going to the meetings and just listening, finding out who these people were and what they were doing,” she said. “At that point, I didn’t understand why they were doing it. But over time, I learned.”

She traced the growing influence of far-right activist Michael Lunsford and his group, Citizens for a New Louisiana, which opposed drag story hours. Further investigation revealed deeper connections.

“There was a guy named David Pitre on the board,” Mejia explained. “He resigned on August ’23. And then I think a month, two months later, Robert Judge comes up with this packet of information on ‘how Marxist the American Library Association is,’ and how ‘the library needs to disaffiliate from the ALA.’

“He sent it to Robert Judge just before he resigned as his parting gift,” she added. “David Pitre is the uncle of (Heritage Foundation President) Kevin Roberts. So there’s a direct line from The Heritage Foundation to Pitre and, through the library board, to Michael Lunsford and his group.”

The Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, opposes abortion, LGBTQ, immigration rights, and racial equity. It is also behind Project 2025, a blueprint for reshaping the federal government to align with conservative principles.

Citizens for a New Louisiana played a key role in the Lafayette Parish Public Library losing one of its tax millages in 2018, significantly reducing its operations. The group has also been involved in library-related disputes in Livingston and St. Tammany parishes.

“So for one month last February, we had a Black History Month display,” Mejia said. “Then the board came back the very next month and banned all displays.”

Erasing Black History from Bookshelves

Carter G. Woodson’s efforts to incorporate Black history into American education led to the establishment of Negro History Week, which evolved into Black History Month. Over the decades, educators and librarians have used the occasion to introduce students to stories and perspectives often absent from mainstream curricula.

However, many of these books are now disappearing from library shelves, much like Lafayette’s Black History Month displays.

“They get around it because they say, ‘We’re banning anything from this place with any kind of sexual content, OK?’” Mejia said. “Like librarians are going to be posting sexual content on display. But the way they got around that was they said, ‘anything political or controversial.’ The librarians here are so scared and so cowed and so many of them have left.”

Vague laws targeting discussions on race have contributed to a broader suppression of diverse voices. Georgia’s 2022 “divisive concepts” law, signed by Governor Brian Kemp in Forsyth County, has led to widespread book challenges. The law has even been cited to justify removing Shakespeare’s works from libraries and banning LGBTQ+ literature.

The legislation was used to terminate Cobb County teacher Katie Rinderle in 2023 for reading My Shadow is Purple, a children’s book about self-acceptance and gender stereotypes. The SPLC is representing Rinderle in a lawsuit challenging her dismissal.

“It’s not a direct challenge of the divisive concepts law, but based on it and its aftereffects,” said Mike Tafelski, interim deputy legal director of the SPLC’s Democracy: Education and Youth litigation team. “It shows you how these vague laws that may be targeting race get interpreted much more broadly to include other communities, as far as what is on the shelves and what isn’t.”

A Library in Decline

Prattville, Alabama, is experiencing a similar crisis. Its library board recently dismissed the director, staff members are leaving, and parts of the building have been shut down due to structural damage.

“We are the poster child of how you lose your library and everything just goes downhill,” said Angie Hayden, co-founder of Read Freely Alabama. “They couldn’t hire somebody if they tried. What librarian is going to come and work in Prattville right now?”

Further complicating matters, Alabama legislators have introduced HB 4, a bill that could severely impact library book selections.

“So they can take this book to your library and say, ‘This is indoctrination propaganda. It’s inappropriate, and I want it removed.’ That librarian then has to make a decision, and I believe it’s 15 days to do it. If they choose to relocate or remove the book completely, that ends it.”

However, librarians who refuse to comply have no recourse.

“If they decide to stand up for the book … there’s no mechanism for them to defend that book,” Hayden warned. “There is no — and I can’t stress this enough — no mechanism by which the librarian can say, ‘This stays and this is why.’”

Source: SPL Center 

Tags: Book bans and censorship in librariesDeep South library control struggleLibrary censorship debatesLibrary funding and free speechLibrary funding battles in Deep SouthPolitical influence on librariesPublic libraries and community rightsPublic libraries under political pressurePublic library access under threatState control over public libraries
Share30Tweet19
Black Politics Now

Black Politics Now

Recommended For You

Appeals court blocks private lawsuits under Voting Rights Act’s disability assistance provision

by Black Politics Now
August 19, 2025
0
Eighth Circuit ruling blocks private suits under Voting Rights Act in 7 states

This provision guarantees that voters who need assistance due to disability, blindness, or inability to read or write are entitled to receive help from a person of their...

Read moreDetails

Who is Rep. Senfronia Thompson, a member of the Texas House Select Committee on Congressional Redistricting

by Black Politics Now
July 27, 2025
0
Who is Rep. Senfronia Thompson, a member of the Texas House Select Committee on Congressional Redistricting

Now serving her 50th year in the Texas Legislature, Thompson is the longest-serving woman and African American in Texas legislative history.

Read moreDetails

WWII USS Utah survivor Clark Simmons’ 1998 Pearl Harbor interview removed from National Park Service website

by Black Politics Now
July 22, 2025
0
WWII USS Utah survivor Clark Simmons’ 1998 Pearl Harbor interview removed from National Park Service website

A significant excerpt from an oral history interview with Clark Simmons, a survivor of the 1941 Pearl Harbor attack aboard the USS Utah, has been removed from the National...

Read moreDetails

What was the 320th Barrage Balloon Battalion? The unsung Black soldiers who protected D-Day’s skies

by Black Politics Now
July 14, 2025
0
What was the 320th Barrage Balloon Battalion? The unsung Black soldiers who protected D-Day’s skies

When Allied forces stormed the beaches of Normandy on June 6, 1944, a little-known but highly specialized all-Black U.S. Army unit was already on the sand, executing a...

Read moreDetails

Who Is Doris Miller, the first Black sailor to receive the Navy Cross for heroism at Pearl Harbor

by Black Politics Now
July 11, 2025
0
Who Is Doris Miller, the first Black sailor to receive the Navy Cross for heroism at Pearl Harbor

Doris “Dorie” Miller was not just a cook in the U.S. Navy—he was a man who redefined courage and patriotism in a military still segregated by race.

Read moreDetails
Next Post
Image Source: WCNC

Clinton College, Johnson C. Smith University impacted by diversity program cuts

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT

Related News

"In 1945, paratroopers of the 555th Parachute Infantry Battalion lined up in their 'jumpsuits' before embarking on a mission. Behind them stands a C-47 aircraft from the Troop Carrier Command, ready to transport them to their destination."— US National Archives

How Black paratroopers saved the US from Japan’s WWII firebombs

April 12, 2025
Image Source: Jessica McGowan/Getty

Racial turnout gap grew in Georgia

December 29, 2024
vertical shot of street with the valentine restaurant sign in nashville usa

City of Memphis plans to hire Judge Bernice Donald to monitor MPD after DOJ report

February 11, 2025
Black Politics Now

Get informed on African American politics with "Black Politics Now," your ultimate source for political engagement.

CATEGORIES

  • Business
  • Civil Rights
  • Congressional Black Caucus
  • Criminal Justice
  • Data
  • Department of Justice
  • Diversity Initiatives
  • Education
  • Elections
  • Enviroment
  • Equity
  • Hate Crimes
  • Health
  • Housing
  • Investigations
  • Legal Defense Fund
  • NAACP
  • Policy
  • Real Estate
  • Reparations
  • Research
  • Sports
  • State Issues
  • Study
  • Supreme Court
  • Technology
  • Voting Rights
  • World

Quick Link

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of service
  • Contact us

Download Our App

© 2024 Black Politics Now | All Right Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpChatIcon
wpChatIcon
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Civil Rights
  • Criminal Justice
  • Education
  • Elections
  • Health
  • Policy
  • Voting Rights
  • Reparations
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Cart
SUBSCRIBE

© 2024 Black Politics Now | All Right Reserved

Join the Movement, Subscribe Now!(Don't worry, we'll never spam you!)

Don’t miss a beat—get the latest news, inspiring stories, and in-depth coverage of the issues that matter most to the Black community. Be part of the conversation and stay connected.

Enter your email address